Statement by Dr. Edwin S. Lyman, Union of Concerned Scientists
Yesterday, the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) issued a permit to Long Mott Energy to construct four small modular reactors (SMRs) adjacent to a Dow chemical plant in Seadrift, Texas. The planned 80-megawatt high-temperature gas-cooled “pebble-bed” reactors being developed by the company X-Energy are of a design never before built in the United States.
Below is a statement from Dr. Edwin Lyman, director of nuclear power safety for the Union of Concerned Scientists.
“This reckless approval represents a failure to protect public health and safety of the highest order.
“The NRC boasts that it issued the construction permit ahead of schedule, following its marching orders from the Trump administration to complete all licensing reviews within 18 months regardless of application complexity. However, the NRC only accomplished this feat by pushing consideration of critical safety questions to a later date—issues the NRC should’ve fully resolved before green lighting construction.
“Chief among these issues is whether the reactor needs a physical containment structure to protect the public from radioactive releases should the highly radioactive reactor fuel overheat and become damaged. The reactor design the NRC approved doesn’t have such a containment. Instead, the safety of the design relies almost entirely on the ability of the reactor fuel to contain radioactive materials even in severe accident scenarios—which has never been demonstrated.
https://nuclearcosts.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/111126_Tschernobyl_2013_1.jpg8531280Web Masterhttps://hastingsgroupmedia.com/website_d72e85d9/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/Nuclearlogo340.svgWeb Master2026-11-11 14:55:152026-11-11 14:55:15Approval of Construction of Four Containment-Free Reactors is Another Clear Sign of a Broken Nuclear Regulatory Commission
Driven by public backlash over skyrocketing utility bills, on election day Georgia voters flipped the Public Service Commission to Democratic control for the first time in decades. Between 2025 and 2026 Georgia voters elected three pro-consumer commissioners. We will now see real change over the next four years as our new commissioners address the overall cost of electricity in Georgia by accelerating affordable renewables and energy efficiency, and reducing Georgia Power’s obscene profits.
Although the historic Georgia elections can be seen as a repudiation of Trump’s policies, what is also true is that allowing seven rate increases in three years, including the largest rate increase in state history of 25% to pay for Plant Vogtle’s massive cost overruns for the two nuclear power reactors that came online in 2023 and 2024, came due. Every Public Service Commissioner who supported new nuclear energy lost their election. And every elected official who was named a “nuclear champion” by the industry-backed Nuclear Matters lost: former PSC Commissioners Fitz Johnson, Tim Echols, and Tricia Pridemore, are gone. The remaining two commissioners in support of Plant Vogtle’s construction and subsequent rate hikes will face voters in 2028.
The political consequences for the Plant Vogtle boondoggle were seen at the Georgia legislature too, where long-term incumbent Don Parsons, chair of the House Energy & Utilities Committee, was defeated. He too received a 2026 “nuclear champion” award. In this year’s legislative session Parson’s tried to insert new nuclear energy as a generation source that must be considered in Georgia Power’s long term energy plan, the Integrated Resource Plan.
These Republican elected officials have caused real harm to Georgians:275,000 Georgians had their power shut off in 2025, or one in nine households. The 25% rate increase for Plant Vogtle’s new reactors, which went into effect in 2024, was the largest contributor to rising costs and caused voters to hold those Commissioners accountable. Georgia voters could not have sent a stronger message: elected officials who serve the interests of Georgia Power instead of their constituents will lose their seats.
With Democrats in control of the Georgia House and the Georgia Public Service Commission, Georgians will now get the affordable solar power that Republicans have blocked for decades at Georgia Power’s request. Common sense policies supporting renewables will advance, finally. Though Georgia is one of the top 10 sunniest states, Georgia ranks 47th for residential solar, and commercial solar, community solar, and balcony solar are nonexistent. That will now change given the election results.
Georgia Power was already spending money on pursuing new nuclear power in Stewart County, because why stop the money train when officials are beholden to powerful monopoly utilities and special interests? Well now they will be stopped.
When I was previously president of the Smart Energy Consumer Collaborative, I was shocked that the Georgia Public Service Commission approved a rate plan that clearly harmed low to moderate income households because of the large monthly fee it imposed, called a demand charge. I knew Georgia Power was a for-profit monopoly, but I did not know they would target poor people, and I did not know our state agency charged with protecting the public interest would allow it. I call that my naïve phase. I had no idea how bad Georgia Power actually was then.
As I began to research what else Georgia Power was doing that was harmful to Georgians, my shock grew to anger: I discovered Plant Vogtle, then the only new nuclear power plant under construction in the United States, was being billed as “U.S. leadership in advancing nuclear technology.”
Really? Why was Georgia, the 10th poorest state in the nation, tasked with achieving nuclear technology leadership for the entire country? If that was a goal, the federal government should be leading.
But that wasn’t the real goal. The real goal was that Georgia Power was building a big expensive thing so that Georgia Power could get big profits under the state’s cost-plus business model where the more money Georgia Power spends, the most profits they make. And because we had Republicans taking money from Georgia Power and delivering their legislative and commercial goals, Plant Vogtle’s new reactors were built with no cost caps and no consumer protections in place. It became the most expensive power plant ever built on Earth, clocking in at $36.8 billion, more than double the original cost estimates.
Georgia Power’s PR spin machine tried to make Georgians proud that we had built new nuclear because we did something no other state could do.
Once people saw their huge power bills and Georgia Power’s huge profits they realized they had been bamboozled. And the rest is electoral history made last night.
While I celebrate the lost careers of those “nuclear champions”, I am still sad and angry over the 275,000 Georgia Power customers who lost electricity in 2025 for inability to pay their huge bills. That is one in nine households, and a public health tragedy that should not have happened. I am angry that Georgia Power is on track to earn a record $3 billion in profits in 2026 in large part from Plant Vogtle’s expansion. And I am angry that Republicans did not understand that their mandate as elected officials is to reduce the suffering of people and make government work to improve lives, but instead consistently voted to expand corporate power and wealth without regard to the impacts of regular people.
A message has been delivered by voters: people matter. Georgia is “not a great place to do business” when its people don’t do well and prosper.
Stay tuned for good things coming from Georgia. And for “nuclear champions” in other states rushing to embrace nuclear power for data centers, take note: that will not end well for you. Heed the message Georgia is sending: do not follow our path.
https://nuclearcosts.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/110626_NuclearStateChampions.png500672Web Masterhttps://hastingsgroupmedia.com/website_d72e85d9/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/Nuclearlogo340.svgWeb Master2026-11-06 11:23:112026-11-06 11:23:11The High Cost of New Nuclear Power Comes Due
Republished with permission from Beyond Nuclear, find original article here.
Are the nuclear startups burying themselves in a deep money pit, asks Linda Pentz Gunter
“Pushing dirt around in an Idaho field,” was the delightful comment left at the end of Iceberg Research’s most recent and damning report about the financial prospects for the multiple nuclear reactor startup companies all vying for customers none of them actually have in what Iceberg calls an “increasingly crowded market.”
The Iceberg analysis was focused on the Berkeley California-based reactor ingenue company, Deep Fission, and its brassy boasts that don’t seem to quite match any actual reality. The September 24, 2026 report’s deliciously punny headline ran: “Deep Fission ($FISN): a Money Pit.” Deep Fission is the company proposing to establish micro-reactors in Parsons, Kansas, dropped into mile-deep boreholes. A citizens’ group called Prairie Dog Alliance — named after local wildlife that is quite adapt at digging deep tunnels itself — has sprung up to oppose the project.
The comment at the end, made by reader Tony Alton, wondered whether another reactor startup, Oklo, and its fairy tale-named Aurora reactor, which will likely remain imaginary, wasn’t an even better company to expose for its overblown hype.
“Excellent report, but surely OKLO is a similar but much larger target ($7B) whose officers are selling large amounts of their personal holdings on a monthly basis,” he wrote. “They have made no apparent progress toward licensing and their construction photos show a dozen pieces of heavy equipment pushing dirt around in an Idaho field.”
The field in question is at the Idaho National Laboratory, but even having that government imprimatur does not seem to have helped Oklo’s fortunes.
Oklo is currently “pushing dirt around” at Idaho National Lab but does not look to be gaining customers or income. (Photo of INL access point, ENERGY.gov/Wikimedia Commons)
The Iceberg report was largely dismissive of Deep Fission’s prospects, saying it would “not be a winner” and wondering whether its debacle on the stock market, where its stocks plummeted almost 11 percent within days, wasn’t just “a late attempt to ride the SMR hype, and dump a stranded asset onto retail investors.”
Around June 18 of this year Deep Fission conducted its initial public offering, known as an IPO, selling 2.5 million shares of stock at $16.00 per share. Then, on September 26, after Iceberg Research released its damning report, describing Deep Fission’s mile-deep borehole reactor technology as overhyped and unlikely to achieve commercial viability, Deep Fission’s stock price fell almost 11 percent, to close at $6.95 per share. By late October, the stocks had plummeted further, decreasing by 56.79% in the space of a month, and closing on October 22 at just $2.30 per share.
The Iceberg report also included some graphs, including one on the fate of the nine other reactor startups that have ventured onto the stock market so far. The graph rather resembles a multi-colored version of Donald Trump’s signature, that is, a lot of scribbling and vertical lines that are mainly headed downward. That trajectory is important and it’s the same for nuclear power as a whole worldwide. There may be some upward blips here and there, but over the long-term it’s a long, slippery downward slope into that money pit abyss, as the Iceberg Research headline warned.
Richard Muller, third from left, and Elizabeth Muller, second from right, with the Berkeley Earth team in 2010. (Photo: Berkeley Earth/Wikimedia Commons)
They have good reason to be nervous, because this isn’t the first venture into the nuclear realm for Deep Fission’s father-daughter founders, Richard Muller and Elizabeth Muller. Ten years ago they launched a nuclear waste technology project, Deep Isolation. As Iceberg noted, that venture is “a deep-borehole nuclear waste disposal company that has failed to commercialize its concept after a decade.” The pair also founded something called Berkeley Earth in 2010 (see photo above.)
Deep Fission, Iceberg concluded, is “largely a repackaging” of the company’s non-starter Deep Isolation.
The nine companies, including Oklo and Deep Fission, that have already gone public, may have been rolling the dice when they first ventured onto the market, but now it looks more like tumbling dice. And their fellow gamblers — that is their investors — are starting to get restless if not downright mad.
There’s precedent here, of course. The country’s so-called flagship SMR company, NuScale, is still facing an on-going class action lawsuit for defrauding its investors after its original SMR project collapsed in 2023, after 16 years and no product. It is also facing potential lawsuits against its officers and/or directors and whether or not they may have engaged in securities fraud or other unlawful business practices.
At least one small modular reactor startup, Holtec — better known for nuclear waste interim storage and reactor decommissioning, even as it endeavors to restart the Palisades, Michigan reactor while also venturing into the SMR field — got the jitters and has withdrawn its IPO for now.
And there could be yet more legal trouble ahead for the 11 reactor projects that have been taken under the auspices of the Department of Energy — all the better to avoid the scrutiny of the Nuclear Regulatory Commission, which at least knows something about nuclear safety; and all the better to avoid any public intervention or the need to conduct environmental reviews, even though this is a violation of federal law under the National Environmental Policy Act, another piece of legislation the Trump administration is trying to destroy.
Fourteen States Attorneys General — plus Harris County, Texas and the District of Columbia— sent a letter to the NRC last August objecting to its rulemaking, ironically entitled Implementation of the National Environmental Policy Act, since that appears to be the opposite of what the NRC is planning to do. The NRC rulemaking instead proposes to make its NEPA implementing regulations less thorough, thereby reducing public confidence in the safety and security of the nuclear sector.
Among other things, the rule would potentially eliminate or at least limit opportunities for public engagement and intervention, doing away with a long tradition of public comment periods during environmental review for nuclear projects.
In keeping with the Trump executive orders to “unleash” and fast track new nuclear projects in the US, the NRC proposed rule would also allow the agency to rush through new nuclear projects without evaluating foreseeable environmental and climate change impacts.
All of this appears to violate statutory obligations under NEPA as required by the Administrative Procedure Act. Accordingly, the Attorneys General urged the NRC to rescind its rulemaking.
So far the NRC, now presumably stripped of most people of conscience thanks to Elon Musk’s early horror movie rampage with his metaphorical chainsaw, has ignored them and is pressing ahead.
Headline photo of the New York Stock Exchange by TomasEE/Wikimedia Commons.
https://nuclearcosts.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/103026_inl_wikim.webp6771024Web Masterhttps://hastingsgroupmedia.com/website_d72e85d9/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/Nuclearlogo340.svgWeb Master2026-10-30 10:00:432026-11-02 11:07:08‘Pushing dirt around in an Idaho field’