The following is an excerpt from an article published recently by the Union of Concerned Scientists and written by Edwyn Lyman, Director, Nuclear Power Safety.

Statement by Dr. Edwin S. Lyman, Union of Concerned Scientists

Yesterday, the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) issued a permit to Long Mott Energy to construct four small modular reactors (SMRs) adjacent to a Dow chemical plant in Seadrift, Texas. The planned 80-megawatt high-temperature gas-cooled “pebble-bed” reactors being developed by the company X-Energy are of a design never before built in the United States.

Below is a statement from Dr. Edwin Lyman, director of nuclear power safety for the Union of Concerned Scientists.

“This reckless approval represents a failure to protect public health and safety of the highest order.

“The NRC boasts that it issued the construction permit ahead of schedule, following its marching orders from the Trump administration to complete all licensing reviews within 18 months regardless of application complexity. However, the NRC only accomplished this feat by pushing consideration of critical safety questions to a later date—issues the NRC should’ve fully resolved before green lighting construction.

“Chief among these issues is whether the reactor needs a physical containment structure to protect the public from radioactive releases should the highly radioactive reactor fuel overheat and become damaged. The reactor design the NRC approved doesn’t have such a containment. Instead, the safety of the design relies almost entirely on the ability of the reactor fuel to contain radioactive materials even in severe accident scenarios—which has never been demonstrated.

Read the full article here.

Driven by public backlash over skyrocketing utility bills, on election day Georgia voters flipped the Public Service Commission to Democratic control for the first time in decades. Between 2025 and 2026 Georgia voters elected three pro-consumer commissioners. We will now see real change over the next four years as our new commissioners address the overall cost of electricity in Georgia by accelerating affordable renewables and energy efficiency, and reducing Georgia Power’s obscene profits.

Although the historic Georgia elections can be seen as a repudiation of Trump’s policies, what is also true is that allowing seven rate increases in three years, including the largest rate increase in state history of 25% to pay for Plant Vogtle’s massive cost overruns for the two nuclear power reactors that came online in 2023 and 2024, came due. Every Public Service Commissioner who supported new nuclear energy lost their election. And every elected official who was named a “nuclear champion” by the industry-backed Nuclear Matters lost: former PSC Commissioners Fitz Johnson, Tim Echols, and Tricia Pridemore, are gone. The remaining two commissioners in support of Plant Vogtle’s construction and subsequent rate hikes will face voters in 2028.

The political consequences for the Plant Vogtle boondoggle were seen at the Georgia legislature too, where long-term incumbent Don Parsons, chair of the House Energy & Utilities Committee, was defeated. He too received a 2026 “nuclear champion” award. In this year’s legislative session Parson’s tried to insert new nuclear energy as a generation source that must be considered in Georgia Power’s long term energy plan, the Integrated Resource Plan.

These Republican elected officials have caused real harm to Georgians:275,000 Georgians had their power shut off in 2025, or one in nine households. The 25% rate increase for Plant Vogtle’s new reactors, which went into effect in 2024, was the largest contributor to rising costs and caused voters to hold those Commissioners accountable. Georgia voters could not have sent a stronger message: elected officials who serve the interests of Georgia Power instead of their constituents will lose their seats.

With Democrats in control of the Georgia House and the Georgia Public Service Commission, Georgians will now get the affordable solar power that Republicans have blocked for decades at Georgia Power’s request. Common sense policies supporting renewables will advance, finally. Though Georgia is one of the top 10 sunniest states, Georgia ranks 47th for residential solar, and commercial solar, community solar, and balcony solar are nonexistent. That will now change given the election results.

Georgia Power was already spending money on pursuing new nuclear power in Stewart County, because why stop the money train when officials are beholden to powerful monopoly utilities and special interests? Well now they will be stopped.

When I was previously president of the Smart Energy Consumer Collaborative, I was shocked that the Georgia Public Service Commission approved a rate plan that clearly harmed low to moderate income households because of the large monthly fee it imposed, called a demand charge. I knew Georgia Power was a for-profit monopoly, but I did not know they would target poor people, and I did not know our state agency charged with protecting the public interest would allow it. I call that my naïve phase. I had no idea how bad Georgia Power actually was then.

As I began to research what else Georgia Power was doing that was harmful to Georgians, my shock grew to anger: I discovered Plant Vogtle, then the only new nuclear power plant under construction in the United States, was being billed as  “U.S. leadership in advancing nuclear technology.”

Really? Why was Georgia, the 10th poorest state in the nation, tasked with achieving nuclear technology leadership for the entire country? If that was a goal, the federal government should be leading.

But that wasn’t the real goal. The real goal was that Georgia Power was building a big expensive thing so that Georgia Power could get big profits under the state’s cost-plus business model where the more money Georgia Power spends, the most profits they make. And because we had Republicans taking money from Georgia Power and delivering their legislative and commercial goals, Plant Vogtle’s new reactors were built with no cost caps and no consumer protections in place. It became the most expensive power plant ever built on Earth, clocking in at $36.8 billion, more than double the original cost estimates.

Georgia Power’s PR spin machine tried to make Georgians proud that we had built new nuclear because we did something no other state could do.

Once people saw their huge power bills and Georgia Power’s huge profits they realized they had been bamboozled. And the rest is electoral history made last night.

While I celebrate the lost careers of those “nuclear champions”, I am still sad and angry over the 275,000 Georgia Power customers who lost electricity in 2025 for inability to pay their huge bills. That is one in nine households, and a public health tragedy that should not have happened. I am angry that Georgia Power is on track to earn a record $3 billion in profits in 2026 in large part from Plant Vogtle’s expansion. And I am angry that Republicans did not understand that their mandate as elected officials is to reduce the suffering of people and make government work to improve lives, but instead consistently voted to expand corporate power and wealth without regard to the impacts of regular people.

A message has been delivered by voters: people matter. Georgia is “not a great place to do business” when its people don’t do well and prosper.

Stay tuned for good things coming from Georgia. And for “nuclear champions” in other states rushing to embrace nuclear power for data centers, take note: that will not end well for you. Heed the message Georgia is sending: do not follow our path.

The Just Solutions Podcast, Episode 38: The Resurgence of Nuclear Power with Dr. Arjun Makhijani, November 5, 2026.

Republished with permission from Beyond Nuclear, find original article here.

Are the nuclear startups burying themselves in a deep money pit, asks Linda Pentz Gunter

“Pushing dirt around in an Idaho field,” was the delightful comment left at the end of Iceberg Research’s most recent and damning report about the financial prospects for the multiple nuclear reactor startup companies all vying for customers none of them actually have in what Iceberg calls an “increasingly crowded market.”

The Iceberg analysis was focused on the Berkeley California-based reactor ingenue company, Deep Fission, and its brassy boasts that don’t seem to quite match any actual reality. The September 24, 2026 report’s deliciously punny headline ran: “Deep Fission ($FISN): a Money Pit.” Deep Fission is the company proposing to establish micro-reactors in Parsons, Kansas, dropped into mile-deep boreholes. A citizens’ group called Prairie Dog Alliance — named after local wildlife that is quite adapt at digging deep tunnels itself — has sprung up to oppose the project.

The comment at the end, made by reader Tony Alton, wondered whether another reactor startup, Oklo, and its fairy tale-named Aurora reactor, which will likely remain imaginary, wasn’t an even better company to expose for its overblown hype.

“Excellent report, but surely OKLO is a similar but much larger target ($7B) whose officers are selling large amounts of their personal holdings on a monthly basis,” he wrote. “They have made no apparent progress toward licensing and their construction photos show a dozen pieces of heavy equipment pushing dirt around in an Idaho field.”

The field in question is at the Idaho National Laboratory, but even having that government imprimatur does not seem to have helped Oklo’s fortunes.

Oklo is currently “pushing dirt around” at Idaho National Lab but does not look to be gaining customers or income. (Photo of INL access point, ENERGY.gov/Wikimedia Commons)

The Iceberg report was largely dismissive of Deep Fission’s prospects, saying it would “not be a winner” and wondering whether its debacle on the stock market, where its stocks plummeted almost 11 percent within days, wasn’t just “a late attempt to ride the SMR hype, and dump a stranded asset onto retail investors.”

Around June 18 of this year Deep Fission conducted its initial public offering, known as an IPO, selling 2.5 million shares of stock at $16.00 per share. Then, on September 26, after Iceberg Research released its damning report, describing Deep Fission’s mile-deep borehole reactor technology as overhyped and unlikely to achieve commercial viability, Deep Fission’s stock price fell almost 11 percent, to close at $6.95 per share. By late October, the stocks had plummeted further, decreasing by 56.79% in the space of a month, and closing on October 22 at just $2.30 per share.

The Iceberg report also included some graphs, including one on the fate of the nine other reactor startups that have ventured onto the stock market so far. The graph rather resembles a multi-colored version of Donald Trump’s signature, that is, a lot of scribbling and vertical lines that are mainly headed downward. That trajectory is important and it’s the same for nuclear power as a whole worldwide. There may be some upward blips here and there, but over the long-term it’s a long, slippery downward slope into that money pit abyss, as the Iceberg Research headline warned.

As for Deep Fission, things are looking bleaker by the week. At least five law firms so far are conducting investigations on behalf of alarmed Deep Fission stockholders, exploring whether Deep Fission has engaged in securities fraud because it surely knew the flimsy basis on which its bold claims of success were made.

Richard Muller, third from left, and Elizabeth Muller, second from right, with the Berkeley Earth team in 2010. (Photo: Berkeley Earth/Wikimedia Commons)

They have good reason to be nervous, because this isn’t the first venture into the nuclear realm for Deep Fission’s father-daughter founders, Richard Muller and Elizabeth Muller. Ten years ago they launched a nuclear waste technology project, Deep Isolation. As Iceberg noted, that venture is “a deep-borehole nuclear waste disposal company that has failed to commercialize its concept after a decade.” The pair also founded something called Berkeley Earth in 2010 (see photo above.)

Deep Fission, Iceberg concluded, is “largely a repackaging” of the company’s non-starter Deep Isolation.

The nine companies, including Oklo and Deep Fission, that have already gone public, may have been rolling the dice when they first ventured onto the market, but now it looks more like tumbling dice. And their fellow gamblers — that is their investors — are starting to get restless if not downright mad.

There’s precedent here, of course. The country’s so-called flagship SMR company, NuScale, is still facing an on-going class action lawsuit for defrauding its investors after its original SMR project collapsed in 2023, after 16 years and no product. It is also facing potential lawsuits against its officers and/or directors and whether or not they may have engaged in securities fraud or other unlawful business practices.

At least one small modular reactor startup, Holtec — better known for nuclear waste interim storage and reactor decommissioning, even as it endeavors to restart the Palisades, Michigan reactor while also venturing into the SMR field — got the jitters and has withdrawn its IPO for now.

And there could be yet more legal trouble ahead for the 11 reactor projects that have been taken under the auspices of the Department of Energy — all the better to avoid the scrutiny of the Nuclear Regulatory Commission, which at least knows something about nuclear safety; and all the better to avoid any public intervention or the need to conduct environmental reviews, even though this is a violation of federal law under the National Environmental Policy Act, another piece of legislation the Trump administration is trying to destroy.

Fourteen States Attorneys General — plus Harris County, Texas and the District of Columbia— sent a letter to the NRC last August objecting to its rulemaking, ironically entitled Implementation of the National Environmental Policy Act, since that appears to be the opposite of what the NRC is planning to do. The NRC rulemaking instead proposes to make its NEPA implementing regulations less thorough, thereby reducing public confidence in the safety and security of the nuclear sector.

Among other things, the rule would potentially eliminate or at least limit opportunities for public engagement and intervention, doing away with a long tradition of public comment periods during environmental review for nuclear projects.

In keeping with the Trump executive orders to “unleash” and fast track new nuclear projects in the US, the NRC proposed rule would also allow the agency to rush through new nuclear projects without evaluating foreseeable environmental and climate change impacts.

All of this appears to violate statutory obligations under NEPA as required by the Administrative Procedure Act. Accordingly, the Attorneys General urged the NRC to rescind its rulemaking.

So far the NRC, now presumably stripped of most people of conscience thanks to Elon Musk’s early horror movie rampage with his metaphorical chainsaw, has ignored them and is pressing ahead.

Headline photo of the New York Stock Exchange by TomasEE/Wikimedia Commons.

Linda Pentz Gunter is the Executive Director of Beyond Nuclear and writes for and edits Beyond Nuclear International. She is the author of the book, No To Nuclear. Why Nuclear Power Destroys Lives, Derails Climate Progress And Provokes War, published by Pluto Press. Any opinions are her own.

Republished with permission from Beyond Nuclear, find original article here.

On September 30, 2026 at the invitation of Massachusetts Democrat Governor Maura Healey representatives and researchers from all six New England Governors (MA, NH, VT, ME, CT, RI) convened at the University of Massachusetts Lowell for the “New England Regional Nuclear Policy Summit”.  All of the New England Governors representative speakers appear to be in lock step for yet another misadventure in reopening the Atomic Pandora’s Box. In fact, the summit attendees would have been enlightened by an opinion piece that appeared the same morning in the CT Mirror by Stanley Heller, Promoting Enduring Peace, “CT’s reckless drive for more nuclear power(opens in new tab)” and well worth all of us to be advised by.

However, there was a hint of caution in extending any further blind faith(opens in new tab) in this current round of nuclear industry hype and lobby funded political champions. There is no rational reason to believe that anything is going to be different from the previous two decades of technological and financial failures of a “nuclear renaissance” that has repeatedly relapsed since it introduction in 2005 with Congress’ passage of the Energy Policy Act of 2005. Of the 34+ “advanced”  reactors that industry offered up and the US Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) generously approved Combined Operating License Applications (combining construction permits and operating licensing in a one stop  shop), on four units broke ground in 2013 while all of the other awarded applicants stepped back to watch.

The two South Carolina units at V.C. Summer Unit 2 and 3 cancelled their construction project midway with a sunk cost of over $9 billion passed onto the state’s captured and irate ratepayers and not a watt of electricity. The SCANA utility responsible for the energy boondoggle collapsed with the company CEO  and senior manager federally convicted of wire and mail fraud to serve prison time. The responsible Westinghouse Electric Senior President of the AP1000 project was also convicted of conspiracy to commit fraud and served time in federal prison.  The Georgia AP1000 Westinghouse project for Vogtle Units 3 and 4 was eventually completed seven years behind schedule at tremendous construction cost overruns. The original estimated cost of completion for Vogtle 3 and 4 was $14 billion turned out to be at least $36 billion to start up.

Nothing has really changed except for the rebranding of the nuclear power technology that small modular reactors (SMR) and micro reactors will be easier, faster  and cheaper to build. In fact, quite the opposite is likely given a lot of small reactors will by all accounts cost more with the loss of the concept of “economies of scale.” Putting nuclear reactors on an assembly line is already decades behind the original energy generating SMR (Small Modular Renewables).

Addressing the gathered governors summit “Nuclear is already part of this region’s ecosystem,” said Sukesh Aghara, UMass Lowell Professor of Nuclear Engineering and Associate Dean of Research . Which Beyond Nuclear agrees is true but not as Prof. Aghara intended it. Every state that ever constructed and operated nuclear power stations, still has all of the high-level radioactive waste in the form of irradiated fuel that remain as virulent pocks on the land with no scientifically proven and socially accepted  long-term management plan for the tens of thousands of years that the waste will need to be isolated.

Outside of the Governors Nuclear Summit, a well attended protest sponsored and organized regionwide had responded to a “Call To Action(opens in new tab)” by the Clamshell Alliance, Citizen Awareness Network  and  the Commonwealth Coalition for Democracy and Safe Energy (CCDSE). The Governors were reminded of the true legacy of nuclear power in their states of unmanaged nuclear waste, the cost of electricity from nuclear power plants ever spirally upwards and the clinical evidence that invisible radioactivity is carcinogenic (causing cancers),  teratogenic (causing genetic damage) and mutagenic (causing birth defects).

Photos courtesy of Shel Horowitz and Susanae Glovaki,  Clamshell Alliance and the Commonwealth Coalition for Democracy and Safe Energy (CCDSE)

Does the “innovation” pitch match the radioactive reality?

DOE/INL 1969 Waste Dumping.

By Leigh Ford, Snake River Alliance

The Department of Energy (DOE) has a problem. They have a nuclear addiction and a growing mountain of toxic, radioactive waste. To solve it, they are eyeing Idaho once again. Governor Little recently signed a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) with the DOE, and they are trying to sell it to us as a “Nuclear Lifecycle Innovation Hub.”

We’re not buying it. This is a nuclear dump dressed up as an “innovation campus,” and DOE is simply hoping that the temptation of jobs and billions of dollars will convince us to turn Idaho into America’s nuclear waste dump.

Recently, I sat down with Roland Beres, who wanted to get the Snake River Alliance’s reaction to the Governor’s signing the MOU with DOE. Roland has a lot of experience following nuclear issues. Notably, he covered events leading up to the Idaho Settlement Agreement, when Governors Batt and Andrus were fighting the feds for sending out-of-state radioactive waste into Idaho. That history matters, because it tells us this isn’t a new fight—it’s the same fight, with slicker marketing.

Today’s political machinery is quickly paving the way for Manhattan Project 2.0, endangering our health and silencing local opposition. Per Executive Order 14300, the Nuclear Regulatory Commission is revising radiation standards and reducing protections for workers and communities. Idaho’s Senate passed SCR 120 to claim that reprocessing nuclear waste fits into the Idaho Settlement Agreement framework. Not to be left out, Idaho’s House passed HB 714, which prohibits local governments from saying “NO” to these dumps and reprocessing facilities in their communities.

The Nuclear Myths

The first myth is money. The DOE isn’t handing Idaho billions of dollars. According to their own request for proposals, they are looking for projects that *prioritize private and state capital*. They offer “targeted, conditional, and time‑limited federal support.” In other words, Idaho taxpayers are on the hook for the cost, while the feds offer a loan and a promise to protect themselves from “open-ended liabilities.”

The second myth is the jobs. Idaho’s response to DOE’s request states we already have the infrastructure and can start fast. That translates to fewer construction jobs. And while the Tech bros designing these untested reactors are boasting that they “practically run themselves,” that means they aren’t going to hire many permanent workers. The promise of “thousands of jobs” is a mirage. We might fix a few roads, but beyond that, thousands of long-term jobs are far-fetched.

The third myth is the waste. Our radioactive legacy can still be seen out at the site in the Arco Desert. Last year, when the Snake River Alliance visited Idaho National Lab I noticed the waste we got from the Three Mile Island meltdown in 1979 is still there, sitting in huge concrete sarcophagi. We saw a warehouse stacked with barrels of waste, much from the Rocky Flats bomb factory—barrels that needed to be recategorized because we have no idea what Colorado actually shipped us. We drove around the 90-acre burial grounds, where a “thousand-year cap” will be placed.

Governor Little might say “that’s all been cleaned up,” but that is dangerously deceptive. We can’t completely clean up nuclear waste. INL has done a good job mitigating a lot of it, but the truth is there is no permanent nuclear waste repository in the country. The waste just keeps piling up, mostly at nuclear power plants back east, and if that waste comes here, it will stay in Idaho permanently. The DOE has a track record of broken promises, and they are not to be trusted.

A Dangerous Bet 

Some politicians and nuclear cheerleaders claim we can reprocess our way out of this. We cannot. Some point to the DOE’s Waste Isolation Pilot Project (WIPP) facility in New Mexico, but it only takes defense-related transuranic waste, and was never meant to be permanent. There have already been two 10-year extensions since 2010, and New Mexico isn’t a solution for Idaho’s burden. New Mexicans don’t want a permanent nuclear dump either.

Idaho is being asked to accept a permanent nuclear burden in exchange for a few temporary construction jobs and mythical money. The waste isn’t leaving. The feds and the nuclear industry have had decades to solve this, and they haven’t. We shouldn’t be the dumping ground for their failures. It is time to reject this dangerous bet and demand a real plan that doesn’t put our people, water, and land at further risk.

Idaho is not America’s dumping ground – not for cash, not for jobs, and not for nuclear waste that outlives our great, great grandchildren’s grandchildren.

Republished with permission from Beyond Nuclear, find original article here.

You would think after the last several weeks we just had, the promoters of nuclear power might be tempering their messages a little. Or even reconsidering their position if they haven’t yet drunk too many gallons of the nuclear Kool-Aid.

But what we are seeing instead is a continued and relentless propaganda campaign re-affirming the “milestones” and “breakthroughs” of new nuclear power projects.

For example, Deep Fission, with its plans to try to drop what could eventually be as many as 100 15MW micro reactors down mile-deep boreholes in the tiny community of Parsons, Kansas (population 9,600), crowed about a recent approval from the US Department of Energy.

Water sources are drying up under climate crisis conditions, but the nuclear bros and their willing political accomplices carry on as if heatwaves, droughts and wildfires simply aren’t happening, ignoring the immense risks they pose to nuclear plants now — and into the future when conditions will be even worse.

What the DOE approved was the company’s Nuclear Safety Design Agreement for its Gravity™ Nuclear Reactor. Deep Fission described this as “a major regulatory milestone.”

What it really amounts to is permission to keep on doodling on the napkin, or, put less snarkily, that they may proceed with their reactor design.

Holtec, the New Jersey-based waste and decommissioning company announced late last month that with the US Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) having granted a License Termination Plan for the closed Oyster Creek Generating Station, the company can now move forward with plans to site four of its SMR-300 reactors at the site.

Collectively, this represents a bigger output than the old 650 MW Oyster Creek reactor, but of course SMR owners are claiming that because their reactors are so much smaller, there need be no emergency evacuation zone or other disaster preparedness beyond the property fence line.

Because after all, what kind of disaster could possibly occur?

Evidently, none of these reactor bros touting their scammy crypto-nukes have been watching the news, since they are just carrying on as if Nothing Happened.

So what didn’t they see? The Romanians dynamiting the Danube river in a desperate attempt to redirect the ever scarcer river water toward their lone Cernavoda nuclear power plant? One reactor there was already closed and now the second one is, as well, as the Danube suffered another drastic drop in water level.

Map provided by ERCC – Emergency Response Coordination Centre/Wikimedia Commons.

That in turn has affected neighboring Moldova which “relies on Romanian power to cover up to 60% of its own electricity shortages,” according to reporting in The Guardian. The loss of Cernavoda could result in power outages, Moldovan authorities warned.

In Hungary, the Paks nuclear power plant was operating at around 10% of its 2,000 MW capacity at time of writing and the Hungarians, like the Romanians, were starting to sink large barges in what is left of the Danube to try to raise water levels and continue to cool the plant.

Then there was the scorched heathland and billowing smoke that obscured the view of the Sizewell nuclear power plant on the English coast just a few miles away. The raging wildfire close to the still operating Sizewell B reactor was a close call, another stroke of luck with the wind blowing the other way. That day.

The nearby precious Minsmere Nature Reserve hasn’t been so lucky, with the fires causing a massive loss of wildlife and habitat. But plans to proceed with the two French Sizewell C EPR reactors have not been abandoned and the UK government insanely granted Sizewell B a 20-year license extension on top of its existing one that would allow it to operate out to 2055.

The plant actually sits on the beach, never mind the fact that climate crisis-caused drastic sea-level rise is an empirical inevitability. And, apparently, never mind the wildfires either, which, with the United Kingdom now in its fifth scorching heatwave of the summer, are only likely to get larger and more frequent.

Exceptionally low water levels in rivers across Europe (August 2026 near Bingen, at the confluence of the Rhine and Nahe rivers shown here) are causing critical shortages of cooling water at nuclear power plants , forcing them to power or shut down. (Photo: ThoBel-0043/Wikimedia Commons.)

Maybe the nuke bros also missed the people fleeing for their lives across Europe while headlines reminded these hapless refugees and others roasting in cities, towns and countryside that their nuclear power plants would not be available to provide the much-needed electricity at a time it was needed most. Instead, people sweltered, and, in some cases, died, from the extreme heat, their villages in some places burned to the ground.

France had to power down and even close many of its reactors due to the extreme heat and then, of course, came the climate change-caused jellyfish swarm at Gravelines, now looking to be an annual event, causing those reactors to close. Jellyfish are a problem because they clog the cooling water intake system.

Meanwhile, parts of the US have been on fire, too, while smoke from Canadian wildfires a few weeks back enveloped a large swath of the Midwest and Northeast in a choking cloud of acrid smoke and falling ash.

So far, and fortunately, there have been no nuclear power plants in the paths of these fires — or some of the catastrophic flooding, including in Texas.

But it really doesn’t stretch the imagination too much to picture a very different scenario.

Nuclear power plants can’t operate well — or sometimes at all— in extreme heat or drought because they require water to cool them and that water needs actually to be cool in the first place. And available.

If the water is too hot or too scarce, nuclear power plants have to reduce power or even shut down altogether.

But when they do, it’s not like turning off a car engine. Because of the highly radioactive and thermally hot fuel inside nuclear reactors —and the fuel pools into which the irradiated fuel rods have been offloaded — they still need cooling. If you can’t cool them, they will eventually melt down. So water must continue to be available and so must electricity to get it there and power the plant.

That is why we have argued for years that nuclear power plants are not reliable, especially in extreme weather conditions. Instead, they are a liability. And with ever more violent weather conditions under the climate crisis, those risks are only going to get worse and disaster more likely.

The events on March 11, 2011 in Japan would have been infinitely less catastrophic, and a whole lot less expensive, if they hadn’t involved a triple nuclear meltdown along with the massive earthquake and tsunami. And, as with Sizewell, they would have been infinitely worse radiologically, had the wind been blowing the other way. Despite this, vast areas received radioactive fallout, complicating rescue efforts of those caught in the earthquake and/or the tsunami.

Fire is one of the biggest risks at a nuclear power plant, largely because of the lethal radioactive inventory on the site. “Irradiation produces a variety of fission products and actinides that multiply the radioactivity in the original uranium fuel by more than 100 million times,” according to The World Nuclear Waste Report (see page 27) published in 2019 by the Heinrich Böll Stiftung. All of this waste currently remains at US reactor sites and at most such around the world, absent a safe, long-term storage solution.

If a raging wildfire engulfed a reactor site, the outcome could be catastrophic, rendering vast areas uninhabitable. Another Chernobyl Zone could be born.

If a fire engulfed a solar or wind farm, that would be a nuisance. The panels or turbines would need to be replaced. But no one would be at risk of thyroid cancer or worse, nor would they need to flee, abandoning their homes and land forever.

Linda Pentz Gunter is the Executive Director of Beyond Nuclear and writes for and edits Beyond Nuclear International. She is the author of the book, No To Nuclear. Why Nuclear Power Destroys Lives, Derails Climate Progress And Provokes War, published by Pluto Press. Any opinions are her own.

 

Headline photo: During the first week of June 2009, Sustainable Resource Alberta burned nearly 8,000 hectares of forest in Western Alberta, just east of the Saskatchewan River Crossing on the Icefields Parkway and Highway 11. The forest was destroyed to bring about greater diversity, stem the spread of mountain pine beetle and to create a fire barrier for any future wild fires. by Cameron Strandberg/Wikimedia Commons.

Institute for Energy Economics & Financial Analysis (IEEFA), Dennis Wamsted, July 9, 2026, First-of-a-kind cooling plan at Fermi Nuclear Project likely to be costly, time-consuming and find the September 17, 2026 webinar here.

Institute for Energy and Environmental Research (IEER), Dr. Arjun Makhijani, June 26, 2026, Nuclear power plant freshwater use – a serious economic and reliability vulnerability. Listen to the November 2026 podcast about this report, here.

By The Nuclear Skeptic

The artificial intelligence bubble is starving for electricity so big tech is teaming up with the administration to “Make America Nuclear Again” – an unaffordable, dangerous alliance forming behind closed doors inside the nation’s capital to resurrect an economically broken and hazardous industry.

Thankfully lawmakers are starting to hear the other side of this story. At a Capitol Hill briefing earlier this month, an esteemed panel of scientific, legal, and regulatory experts issued a stark warning to lawmakers: the rush to expand nuclear energy by gutting safety regulations poses catastrophic risks to public safety, national security, and global climate resilience and will thwart affordability goals. Hosted by Ralph Nader and organized by Beyond Nuclear and the Nuclear Information and Resource Service (NIRS), the briefing presented a sobering look at an industry attempting to bypass democratic oversight with the full backing of the Trump White House.

The core driver of this massive atomic push is the artificial intelligence bubble, allowing speculative tech companies with little to no experience building nuclear power plants to assume huge amounts of debt, set aside climate goals, and drive the electricity grid to the brink of collapse. Physicist and former Department of Energy Under Secretary, Dr. Joe Romm, explained how tech’s hunger for baseload electricity is driving a calculated strategy that blocks affordable renewable energy deployment in favor of continued fossil-fuel generation and fast-tracked nuclear development. To build reactors quickly, the administration is aggressively pushing to curtail the authority and independence of the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC).

Former NRC Commissioner Peter Bradford warned that stripping the agency of its oversight is an alarming step backward for an already compromised regulator. Nuclear proponents seek to rubber-stamp unproven reactor designs and bypass long-standing public health and environmental protections.

The industry’s aspirations rely heavily on small modular nuclear reactors (SMRs) and “advanced” fast-reactor designs, marketed by billionaires as inherently safe and revolutionary. However, Dr. M.V. Ramana, a professor at the University of British Columbia, dismantled these claims during the briefing. He emphasized that deregulation will not magically solve nuclear power’s chronic history of multi-billion-dollar cost overruns and decades-long construction delays, pointing to the financial disaster of Plant Vogtle in Georgia as a prime example of the industry’s systemic failure.

Adding a chilling dimension to the briefing, Dr. Edwin Lyman of the Union of Concerned Scientists sounded the alarm on the administration’s unprecedented plan to distribute Cold War-era surplus plutonium to private startups, such as Oklo, for fuel. Lyman warned that treating weapons-usable plutonium as a standard commercial commodity bypasses rigorous safety analyses, introducing severe public safety and nuclear proliferation hazards that haven’t been seen in decades.

The briefing also emphasized how fast-tracking nuclear power actively undermines climate adaptation. Environmental attorney Diane Curran illustrated that by circumventing crucial federal laws like the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA), the NRC is completely failing to account for how climate-driven weather hazards—such as severe flooding, droughts, and extreme temperatures—imperil reactor stability over their lifespans.

Furthermore, Sharon Squassoni of George Washington University highlighted the ominous militarization of the civil nuclear sector. Civil reactors are now being prepared to power military installations and kinetic AI weapon systems. Squassoni warned that this blurring of civilian and military lines enables developers to sidestep traditional NRC regulation entirely, heightening global weapons proliferation risks and setting a dangerous international precedent.

Ultimately, the panel of experts concluded that sacrificing public safety to satisfy the short-term power demands of tech conglomerates is a profound and potentially catastrophic mistake. While the nuclear industry peddles speculative “paper” reactor designs that will take decades to materialize, safe, reliable, and affordable renewable energy can be deployed rapidly today. The briefing left lawmakers with a crystal-clear message: the public must not bear the existential and financial risks of an unregulated atomic grift.