By Patty Durand

On April 30, 2024, Georgia Power finally completed the first new nuclear reactors in the U.S. in 30 years. But for Georgia Power customers, the project did not come with a celebration. It came with a 25% rate increase the day after the two reactors entered commercial service, the largest rate increase in state history. All of this as Georgia Power rakes in record profits,  by some accounts as much as 23% of consumer electric bills.

And Plant Vogtle came with its own “Let them eat cake” moment for Georgians: On May 31, 2024, U.S. Energy Secretary Jennifer Granholm joined federal and state officials at a ribbon-cutting ceremony on site in Waynesboro, Georgia. There, she called for building 200 more Westinghouse AP1000 reactors without mentioning the project’s whopping $36 billion price tag, while attendees were literally treated to cake shaped like nuclear reactors. Not only was Secretary Granholm not a Georgia Power customer and thus not impacted, none of the state Public Service Commission (PSC) commissioners regulating Georgia Power were either: they were all Georgia EMC customers.

Regulatory Failure

Throughout construction, as cost overruns ran into the billions of dollars, these same regulators declined to put consumer protections in place, claiming that a thorough review to determine what costs were prudent and reasonable would take place at the end. Yet that final, thorough review never happened. Georgia is one of only five states with no Consumer Utility Counsel or Advocate to represent consumers in complex, billion-dollar rate cases. For Vogtle, that absence had profound consequences: as the project neared completion after 7 years of delay, PSC staff and Georgia Power reached an agreement in private under which nearly all cost overruns would be passed directly to customers, with no public hearings or thorough prudency review.

Because those hearings were never held, there is little national understanding of the drivers of the cost overruns, allowing all kinds of beliefs about new nuclear energy to take root without a factual record. Consultants hired in the spring of 2023 by the commission prepared reports for what were expected to be weeks of cost review hearings that fall. Those reports never saw the light of day, but we know they concluded that most of the cost overruns should not be borne by customers.

Next Time Won’t Be Better

What does that have to do with the national push for new nuclear power underway now? There is a strong belief among proponents that the next time will be different, that a learning curve exists from Georgia’s experience. Claims that Unit 4 was cheaper to build, or that there was any meaningful learning curve, are not backed up by facts or documentation. If that were true reports documenting that amazing outcome would be public and news stories would proliferate, but neither exists.

In fact, nearly every major claim made leading up to and throughout the project was false. Georgia Power claimed for years that Plant Vogtle was on time and on budget when it wasn’t. South Carolina Electric & Gas and Westinghouse made false claims of progress on their twin nuclear project at V.C. Summer, using the same AP1000 reactor design as Georgia, leading to criminal charges and massive fines for both utility and Westinghouse executives when the truth was revealed.

Important Repercussions

The political fallout in Georgia has been significant too. Last November, two Public Service Commissioners who backed Vogtle were removed by voters in decisive elections, the first time in 30 years that Democrats were elected to the commission. The following month, a special election flipped a traditionally Republican-held seat to a Democrat who campaigned on Public Service Commission accountability. And last month, a third Public Service Commissioner, a staunch nuclear power advocate, announced she would not seek reelection.

This is what makes the current push for nuclear power so troubling. It is happening at a time when the economics of energy have fundamentally changed. Renewable energy, especially solar and wind paired with battery storage, is dramatically cheaper and faster to deploy than nuclear power projects. Flexibility is what a modern grid needs now, not the large baseload generating power plants and high voltage transmission lines of the past. By pursuing new nuclear and natural gas for data centers, Georgia is looking backward. Anyone following this path is too.

The truth is that Texas deployed 30 gigawatts of solar generation and 6 gigawatts of storage in just the past four years at a cost of about $36 billion. Georgia deployed 2 gigawatts of nuclear generation over 15 years also at a cost of about $36 billion. That is typical for nuclear power: projects are either cancelled at great cost to ratepayers as in South Carolina, or are built at great cost to ratepayers as in Georgia. 

Profits Over People

So why are the voices promoting nuclear generation only growing louder? The answer appears to be an outdated view of the electricity grid among some, and the pursuit of profits among others. This dynamic is clear from the substantial profits that Plant Vogtle delivers to Georgia Power. Westinghouse, Small Modular Reactor (SMR) startups, and other utilities are eager to pursue big profits from nuclear power too. Even more disturbing, the Trump administration announced a $6 billion merger of Trump Media and nuclear fusion company TAE Technologies, while it relaxes nuclear safety protocols that benefit allies. 

Plant Vogtle offers a cautionary tale to the country: eighteen months after Georgia Public Service Commissioners enjoyed cake in the shape of nuclear reactors, two of them were gone. This year, a third commissioner will be gone. Elected officials must understand that voters will not reward you for pursuing nuclear power: they will remove you.

The following is an excerpt from an article published recently by the Union of Concerned Scientists and written by Edwyn Lyman, Director, Nuclear Power Safety.

April 26, 2026 marks the 40th anniversary of the Chernobyl Unit 4 nuclear power plant disaster in the former Soviet Union. A toxic combination of defective reactor design, deficient safety analysis, disregard for operating procedures and administrative controls, prioritization of power production over safety, lack of independent regulatory oversight —and, above all, excessive secrecy—led to the worst nuclear reactor accident in history.

Operators botched a safety test and took the reactor into an unstable state, causing a rapid rise in power that triggered violent steam explosions that blew apart the reactor core and surrounding structures. Fires burned for days. A massive amount of radioactivity dispersed across the former Soviet Union and much of Europe. Hundreds of thousands of individuals were evacuated or relocated from contaminated areas, and a 30-kilometer radius “exclusion zone” was established that is still in place today. Dozens of emergency personnel died within weeks from acute radiation syndrome, and thousands of children developed thyroid cancer from radioactive iodine exposure. Ultimately, tens of thousands of cancer cases throughout Europe are projected to occur from the radioactive pollution caused by the disaster.

The United States and many other countries have sought to distance themselves from the potential for a Chernobyl-like accident by asserting that their nuclear regulators would never have licensed a reactor with the safety flaws of the RBMK (a Russian acronym for “high-power channel-type reactor,” the Chernobyl-4 design), and that light-water reactors (LWRs), by far the most common type of power reactor in operation, are far safer. While this argument has some validity, soon after the accident it became clear the safety benefits of LWRs compared to the Chernobyl-4 RBMK were not as great as advertised—a point later illustrated by the 2011 Fukushima Daiichi triple LWR meltdown in Japan. And today, many of the regulatory requirements and standards that underlie this confidence in the safety of the US nuclear fleet are being thrown by the wayside as the Trump administration recklessly pushes to “unleash” nuclear energy as quickly as possible.

Read the full article here.

By Sharon Squassoni

President Donald J. Trump’s recent threats to end civilization in Iran gave many a nuclear weapons expert the jitters. For them, existential threats mean only one thing: use of nuclear weapons.  Thankfully, Trump’s April 7, 2026 threats were empty and possibly just a ruse to create a dramatic background for the temporary ceasefire in Iran.  To be clear, the use of nuclear weapons in combat would serve no earthly strategic or tactical purpose, but threats to use them can be potent: even a latent capability in the hands of Iran was regarded as too threatening for the United States to tolerate any longer, which reportedly drove the U.S. and Israeli military actions.

It’s hard to tell who’s winning or losing in this conflict, but already it’s clear that disruption of energy sources (Iran’s blocking the Straits of Hormuz and the U.S. and Israel striking Iran’s oil infrastructure) focuses attention like no other infrastructure attack.  A sudden cutoff that shrinks supplies and distorts prices echoes in economies across the globe.  This is one reason the world was hesitant to impose sanctions on Iran’s oil some twenty years ago when Iran’s clandestine nuclear program was first unveiled.  Today, the Iran war has underscored just how dependent the world continues to be on foreign sources of oil. 

Would nuclear energy be any different?

Since 2022, there has been a push in Europe and elsewhere to deploy nuclear reactors to reduce dependencies on Russian oil and gas, triggered by Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.  But such a response is almost laughable to anyone paying attention to what has transpired in Ukraine in the last four years.  Russia hesitated not at all to hold the Chernobyl and Zaporizhzhiya nuclear power plants hostage, in addition to firing upon them.  The only thing that has saved Ukraine from a major nuclear meltdown is the fact that Russia wants to save Ukraine for itself, rather than destroy it utterly. Such vulnerability works both ways: in August 2025, an auxiliary transformer at Russia’s Kursk nuclear power plant (the largest in Russia) caught fire after Russian forces shot down Ukrainian drones. 

For those who still believe in international laws, there are rules to prevent attacks on nuclear plants — specifically the Protocol I Additional to the Geneva Conventions, a key document in international humanitarian law adopted in 1979 — that 175 countries follow.  Unfortunately, Russia withdrew in 2019 and the US has never ratified Protocol I (along with Israel, India, Pakistan, Turkey and Iran).  The Protocol protects “works and installations containing dangerous forces,” prohibiting attacks on nuclear power plants that generate civilian electricity, among other things.  It concedes that some nuclear power plants that regularly support military purposes may be attacked.  For those paying attention to nuclear development trends, this should be worrisome because both China and the United States have programs to develop nuclear reactors for specific military uses. Not content to learn from past experience, the United States plans to deploy a military microreactor by July 4th of this year. Leaving aside questions of cost, safety and peacetime security, such deployments will widen the base of deadly targets in war.  Civilians won’t care whether international law deems these “legitimate” targets of attack.

Attacks on nuclear facilities themselves are not new. The United States, Russia, Israel, Iran and Iraq have all, at times, targeted nuclear research and power reactors under various stages of construction and operation in the past.  Sometimes these attacks tried to slow nuclear weapons proliferation programs and sometimes, as in the Iran-Iraq war, they were targeted for less specific purposes.  After the June 2025 attacks on uranium enrichment-related facilities by the United States, touted as “obliterating” Iran’s nuclear program, International Atomic Energy Agency Director General Rafael Grossi warned that a strike on the Bushehr power plant could cause a regional catastrophe.   

Recently, Iran’s Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi has claimed that the Bushehr plant, which generates close to 1000 Megawatts of electricity, has been struck four times since February this year.  The closest hit has been 75 meters from the plant on April 4, killing a security guard and damaging a building. Russia, which has 128 Rosatom personnel at the plant, is considering further evacuations, which sounds eerily similar to what happened to the Zaporizhzhia plant in March 2022. 

To create a nuclear disaster, it’s not necessary to directly hit the containment building. Damaging on-site and off-site power necessary for cooling can also have severe repercussions. In the case of Zaporizhzhia, operators shut down reactors to minimize some of the risks. But even reactors in stand-by modes pose radioactive risks in a war zone.  The Bushehr power plant is still operating and has spent nuclear fuel on-site in spent fuel pools. Who can forget the video footage of the Fukushima Daiichi nuclear power plant in 2011 when crews attempted to spray seawater from helicopters on spent fuel pools damaged by the earthquake and tsunami that devastated Japan?  More than a decade later, the site is still undergoing remediation.

In spite of all this, Director General of the IAEA Grossi promotes rules of the road to help nuclear energy continue operating in warzones.  It is a stark reminder that the IAEA’s major mission is to promote nuclear energy, despite the emerging lessons from two “nuclearized” wars.

In fact, learning the wrong lessons from this conflict could carry the seeds of unimaginable future disruption.  A world that fears reliance on foreign energy could rely even more on nuclear energy for not just electricity, but transportation and data processing, the new currency of power.  The greater the reliance, the keener officials will be to keep it up and running.  More and more widely distributed nuclear targets will not be protected by Protocol I of the Geneva Convention, or by the International Atomic Energy Agency.  There is no International Nuclear Red Cross or Emergency Management Agency.  

Many Americans find it hard to contemplate attacks on U.S. soil, with good reason.  This is why the 9/11 attacks affected the population so deeply.  Those attacks sparked significant improvements in security at nuclear power plants that are now being unraveled by a push to deploy nuclear reactors in the United States as quickly as possible.  The Nuclear Regulatory Commission recently voted to discontinue force-on-force commando drills designed to reveal weaknesses in site vulnerabilities. A victim of the DOGE process, the NRC has been stripped of its independence and will now overhaul the entire licensing process, even as the Trump administration seeks to end-run the NRC by deploying new reactors on government sites owned by the Departments of Energy and Defense. 

If anything, the Iran war demonstrates Gulliver’s dilemma. Both Ukraine and Iran have used drones successfully to compensate for conventional force inferiority.  Are we truly prepared to counter cheaper and more plentiful attacks that are more difficult to detect and defend against?  

Iran’s nuclear program was feared for its potential to provide the basis for nuclear weapons.  Now it is generating fear for its potential to provoke a more imminent regional catastrophe, whether intended or accidental.  These security risks, perhaps not widely appreciated now, will only grow in a more nuclearized future.

Sharon Squassoni
Research Professor
Elliott School of International Affairs,
The George Washington University

By The Nuclear Skeptic

Earlier this week, ProPublica published a damning exposé detailing how the Trump administration is aggressively overhauling the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) to rapidly expand nuclear power, ostensibly to meet the immediate energy demands of artificial intelligence. Starting with the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE), coined and implemented by Elon Musk, the nuclear DOGE bros are injecting a Silicon Valley “move fast and break things” mentality into arguably the most important safety regulator on the planet.

This push to rubber stamp nuclear power projects includes mandates to speed up the approval of new nuclear reactors, including Small Modular Reactors (SMRs) that have never been built or operated in the U.S., rewriting or removing longstanding safety rules, and critically downsizing the agency. The drastic shift has sparked a mass exodus of seasoned experts, with over 400 staff members having left the NRC since the administration took office. Career officials warn that the incoming DOGE operatives lack basic nuclear policy experience and are actively undermining the independent safety culture that has prevented a major U.S. nuclear disaster since the accident at Three Mile Island Unit 2 in 1979 (conveniently renamed/rebranded recently to the Crane Clean Energy Center as efforts are underway to restart Unit 1, the other closed reactor at the site to power data centers for Microsoft).

The ProPublica report highlights several alarming internal incidents, like this particularly awful nugget:

On the agenda that day: the future of nuclear energy in the Trump era. The meeting was convened by 31-year-old lawyer Seth Cohen. Just five years out of law school, Cohen brought no significant experience in nuclear law or policy; he had just entered government through Elon Musk’s Department of Government Efficiency team.

As Cohen led the group through a technical conversation about licensing nuclear reactor designs, he repeatedly downplayed health and safety concerns. When staff brought up the topic of radiation exposure from nuclear test sites, Cohen broke in.

“They are testing in Utah. … I don’t know, like 70 people live there,” he said.

“But … there’s lots of babies,” one staffer pushed back. Babies, pregnant women and other vulnerable groups are thought to be potentially more susceptible to cancers brought on by low-level radiation exposure, and they are usually afforded greater protections.

“They’ve been downwind before,” another staffer joked.

“This is why we don’t use AI transcription in meetings,” another added.

But one of the more disturbing revelations was buried a little further into the report:

An increasingly vocal group of industry voices and deregulation advocates have blamed the slow build-out on overly cautious and inefficient regulators. Among the most powerful exponents of this view are billionaires Peter Thiel and Marc Andreessen; both venture capitalists have their own investments in the nuclear energy sector and are influential Trump supporters.

Andreessen camped out at Mar-a-Lago, Trump’s private club in Florida, after Trump won the 2024 election, helping pick staff for the new administration. In late 2024, Thiel personally vetted at least one candidate for the Office of Nuclear Energy, according to people familiar with the conversations. Neither responded to requests for comment.

Peter Thiel, everyone’s favorite Antichrist-obsessed, nefarious billionaire, is handpicking his own regulator? While most may be more familiar with Thiel’s technocratic AI and surveillance ventures, very little has been reported about his desire to monopolize the fuel supply for an entire fleet of new nuclear reactors designed to use “nuclear weapons usable uranium.” 

General Matter, Thiel’s Uranium Enrichment startup, aims to supply High-Assay Low-Enriched Uranium (HALEU) for new reactors by 2030, and they’ve already broken ground at their facility in Paducah, KY – backed with significant funding from the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) (aka – you the taxpayer). 

This should give everyone more pause than it has.

Before it was public knowledge that Thiel sought to supply “weapons-usable” uranium fuel to an entire fleet of new reactors, five of the world’s leading experts on nuclear safety and weapons proliferation warned the Biden Administration about the potential catastrophe with a new fleet of reactors designed to run on HALEU: 

The decision on how to handle HALEU domestically has crucial downstream consequences for global security. Were HALEU to become a standard reactor fuel without appropriate restrictions determined by an interagency security review, other countries would be able to obtain, produce, and process weapons-usable HALEU with impunity, eliminating the sharp distinction between peaceful and nonpeaceful nuclear programs. Such countries would be only days away from a bomb, giving the international community no warning of forthcoming nuclear proliferation and virtually no opportunity to prevent it. An unfettered HALEU policy leaves no margin of safety.

Wonderful. Thiel has set himself up to be the sole producer of weapons usable uranium to fuel experimental, unproven nuclear reactor designs (many of which are being pushed for by other billionaires), and hand-picked the regulator making sure he paints within the lines for a technology that can be catastrophically unforgiving. Nothing more to see here…

By The Nuclear Skeptic

Diane Wilson, a 78-year old, fourth-generation Texas shrimper, and leader of the San Antonio Bay Estuarine Waterkeeper (SABEW) is approaching her third week of a hunger strike outside Dow Chemical’s Seadrift manufacturing facility along the Texas gulf coast. On March 2nd, Wilson began protesting two simultaneous environmental threats posed by the corporation, the same company responsible for the worst environmental disaster in history: Dow’s Union Carbide India Limited pesticide plant in Bhopal, India. While she is fighting an unprecedented request by Dow to discharge plastic pollution into the San Antonio Bay estuary, Wilson also demands that Dow and partner X-energy immediately withdraw the company’s plans to build unshielded experimental nuclear reactors at the Seadrift facility. Wilson has stated unequivocally that she will not end her strike until her demands are met.

At the center of the growing controversy is Dow’s ambition to construct four “small” nuclear reactors on the Seadrift plastics site. The corporation is advancing this project through its subsidiary, Long Mott Energy LLC. Local activists, including Diane Wilson, are raising alarms due to the deeply experimental nature of the proposed reactors. According to the plans, the company is using a reactor design with no conventional steel-reinforced concrete containment structure, which stands in stark contrast to every existing U.S. nuclear plant. Furthermore, this specific nuclear reactor design has never been tested, licensed or built anywhere in the country.

Beyond the unproven reactor design, the project presents a severe long-term environmental hazard as the reactors would generate high-level nuclear waste. Because there is currently no licensed permanent repository for such dangerous, highly radioactive waste anywhere in the U.S., it  would have to be stored on-site at the Seadrift facility indefinitely. For local residents like Diane, adding a permanent nuclear waste dump to an already heavily industrialized coastline is an unacceptable risk. “Dow can’t keep plastic out of our bay,” Wilson said. “Now they want to run reactors that have never been built or licensed in this country, next to our waters near our homes, and that’s just crazy”.

To block the proposed nuclear development, SABEW has taken the fight directly to federal oversight agencies. Represented by the Austin-based law firm Perales, Allmon & Ice, PC, the group has successfully intervened before the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission’s (NRC) Atomic Safety and Licensing Board. Through this legal intervention, SABEW is actively challenging Dow’s pending construction permit application, the first to be filed for such a reactor design. In conjunction with the hunger strike, Wilson’s demand letter makes clear that Dow must cancel all plans to build nuclear reactors at the site. It additionally requires that the corporation formally withdraw its construction permit application from the NRC.

The protest has already triggered physical confrontations with the chemical giant’s corporate security personnel. On March 9, when SABEW members attempted to deliver their formal demand letter to the facility’s site director, they were intercepted by Dow’s head of security, John Weitz. Weitz informed the group that interim director Thomas Welch had replaced former site director Heather Lyons, and offered to “handle” the letter himself. When SABEW insisted on delivery to a senior official, Weitz ordered them to stop video recording and told them they were on private property. He specifically threatened Wilson with arrest if she set foot on Dow property, citing her history of a 2002 action at the facility where she scaled an 80-foot chemical tower to unfurl a banner regarding the aforementioned deadly Bhopal disaster.

Shortly after this exchange, Calhoun County sheriff’s officers arrived. The authorities presented Wilson and a SABEW member with a formal order to sign, bearing Weitz’s name, stating that they would be arrested if found on Dow property. When the group requested a copy of the order they had been asked to sign, they were told they could not have one. Consequently, the demand letter is being sent directly to Fitterling at Dow’s headquarters in Midland, Michigan.

While the experimental nuclear reactors represent a massive future threat, they compound an existing environmental crisis. Dow’s Seadrift facility currently manufactures nurdles, pre-production plastic pellets used as raw material for consumer goods. Globally, an estimated one billion pounds of nurdles enter the oceans each year. SABEW has collected millions of these pellets around the facility, including millions collected in a single spot in the Victoria Barge Canal on New Year’s Eve 2025. Instead of upgrading pollution controls to meet its existing permit—which limits discharges to “trace amounts” of “floating solids”—Dow is asking the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality to rewrite the rules. The company has proposed no replacement limit, seeking an unprecedented permit that would explicitly allow it to discharge plastics into the bay.

Despite the physical toll of her fast and the threat of legal retaliation, Wilson remains encamped. “This bay belongs to the people of Texas, not to Dow Chemical,” she said

HOW TO TAKE ACTION:

Diane and SABEW would like to invite all stakeholders to sign-on to her letter demanding their permit include zero discharge of plastics (pellets, powder, and flakes) from Dow’s Seadrift facility, and cancellation of its plans to build nuclear reactors. The sign-on is open to all organizations globally. There is no current deadline set as they plan to continue to send the letter with updated sign-ons until they receive a response or until the demands are met. Tell Dow to STOP NOW! Read the letter and sign-on here.

In Georgia, the political fallout from nuclear power is no longer theoretical—it is electoral. On May 19, 2024, state officials enjoyed cake in the shape of nuclear reactors at the Plant Vogtle ribbon cutting in Waynesboro to celebrate the completion of the first two nuclear reactors built in the United States in 30 years. Just 18 months later, two of those pro-nuclear regulators, Commissioners Tim Echols and Fitz Johnson, were gone, ejected in landslide numbers by voters who did not like the huge utility bills that followed. Six months later, a third pro-nuclear regular, Commissioner Trisha Pridemore, announced that she would not run for reelection.

This fallout was of their own making: Plant Vogtle’s total cost of $36 billion marks it as the most expensive power plant ever built on earth. The project went $17 billion over budget and was delivered seven years late. Yet Georgia’s pro-utility regulators had only positive things to say throughout construction, then voted to make customers reimburse Georgia Power for nearly all of Vogtle’s cost overruns while granting them profits far above industry norms. Allowing billions in cost overruns to flow directly into customer bills raised rates a stunning 25%, the largest rate increase in state history, one that will last across the 60-year depreciation schedule for the reactors.

This harmful financial outcome for customers was predictable. Many nuclear energy experts, as well as commission staff, testified both before the project began in 2008 and again in 2017—after massive overruns drove main contractor Westinghouse Electric Company into bankruptcy—that the project should be scrapped. The financial risks for Georgians were too high, they said, and less expensive generation was available. Public opposition was strong too. All were ignored by regulators who voted to continue. 

Meanwhile, as Georgia Power customers experienced high bills, Georgia Power received record profits. The contrast is stark: while customers experience utility bills the size of car payments, in 2024 Georgia Power enjoyed record profits of $2.5 billion, and in 2025 profits were a stunning $2.85 billion. These profits are far higher than a monopoly market delivering an essential commodity, electrons, should earn, and would not earn without state protectionism. 

What comes with high utility bills? High customer disconnections. In 2025, Georgia Power disconnected approximately 275,000 customers, or one in nine Georgia Power households compared to a national average of only 1%.

The irony is striking: Georgia’s state officials celebrate grid reliability while overlooking a fundamental reality—electricity is not reliable for customers who cannot afford it. Even setting aside that Georgia Power’s reliability metrics fall below the national average, when a household is disconnected the grid is no longer reliable for the people it is meant to serve.

The political consequences are now spreading beyond Georgia. Lawmakers in Alabama are advancing proposals to eliminate elections for the Alabama Public Service Commission after watching Georgia voters elect two Democrats from their regulatory body following Vogtle-related rate increases. So rather than adjust energy policy to reduce consumer risk, policymakers seek to reduce voter oversight instead. 

Georgia’s experience demonstrates that when nuclear construction drives electricity prices sharply upward, voters hold regulators accountable. If elections are weakened or eliminated in response to nuclear-driven rate backlash, it signals that policymakers understand the financial risks but prefer to shield regulators from consequences rather than protect customers.

Despite the first nuclear reactor construction project in 30 years going off the rails, several states are now exploring nuclear construction using the same AP1000 reactor design that Georgia Power used. Policymakers in New York, Texas, South Carolina, and Pennsylvania have all discussed, or initiated, pathways for advanced or large-scale nuclear expansion involving Westinghouse technologies.

The discussion is particularly notable in South Carolina given the state’s similar nuclear construction project to Georgia’s. In 2017 that state ended its V.C. Summer nuclear project given that cost overruns had already raised bills nine times with no end in sight. Some South Carolina regulators and Westinghouse officials went to jail or paid hundreds of millions in fines for lying about cost estimates and construction progress.

The job of a commissioner is to balance utility financial viability with affordable bills, but instead Georgia’s regulators allowed costs that ballooned from construction delays, contractor failures, and project mismanagement to be transferred to Georgia Power customers. Georgia regulators thought voters wouldn’t see past their infrastructure promises while they ignored utility bill affordability, but electricity is not a luxury. It is a necessity. When bills rise but profits soar for the utility, voters correctly interpret the situation and move to end the political careers for those driving it.

Georgia’s experience should serve as a warning to those now pursuing nuclear power, few of whom understand what happened in Georgia. When nuclear construction costs spiral – and they always do because nuclear construction is the only generation type that does not go down in cost over time – voters rightfully hold regulators responsible for the surge in electricity bills. Regulators will not be thanked for building nuclear power. They will be removed.

Nuclear fallout reshaped Georgia’s political landscape, propelling two Democrats onto the state’s utility regulatory commission and prompting a third to drop out. 

The lesson is clear: costly energy decisions do not remain confined to regulatory dockets—they are judged at the ballot box. State officials who fail to protect consumers will be replaced. 

Byline: Patty Durand is the founder of Georgians for Affordable Energy, a nonprofit that advocates for fair utility rates and responsible energy policy in Georgia.

By The Nuclear Skeptic

In a significant win for local opposition, the Nuclear Regulatory Commission’s (NRC) Atomic Safety and Licensing Board has granted a petition to intervene in the licensing process for Dow/X-energy’s proposed small modular nuclear reactor (SMR) project, the first of its kind to apply for a construction permit. The decision marks a pivotal victory for the San Antonio Bay Estuarine Waterkeeper, a local environmental advocacy group representing fisherpeople and community members who have long opposed the project and have dealt with water contamination stemming from Dow’s operation in Seadrift, Texas for decades.

The ruling effectively halts the immediate progression of the construction permit application for the Long Mott Generating Station (LMGS). The facility, proposed by Long Mott Energy (LME)—a subsidiary of the chemical giant Dow and Union Carbide (yes, the same Union Carbide responsible for the most deadly environmental disaster in history)—aims to construct four pebble-bed nuclear reactors in Seadrift. While the project has been touted as one of the first of its kind globally, the Licensing Board found that financial concerns raised by local petitioners merit intervention. The Board could ultimately deny the construction permit, placing the future of the Dow/X-Energy collaboration in jeopardy as well as other proposed X-energy reactors, including at the Hanford Nuclear Site on the Columbia River in Washington state. 

At the heart of the Waterkeeper’s successful petition is the contention that LME has failed to demonstrate the necessary financial qualifications to build and operate a nuclear facility safely. These concerns regarding financial viability were sharply underscored by recent corporate developments. Just days prior to the NRC’s decision, Dow announced a “restructuring” involving the elimination of 4,500 jobs, constituting nearly 15 percent of its global workforce. Many of these cuts are slated for Texas, with specific impacts on the Seadrift area. This juxtaposition of mass layoffs with an overly ambitious, capital-intensive nuclear construction project, prone to runaway cost escalations, has fueled the Waterkeeper’s argument that the project lacks the financial stability required for such a high-risk venture.

Despite the admission of their financial contention by the NRC, San Antonio Bay Waterkeeper expressed significant disappointment regarding the NRC’s dismissal of their safety concerns, albeit on a technicality. Nuclear safety expert, Dr. Edwin Lyman, asserted that the proposed X-Energy Xe-100 design—a “first-of-a-kind” pebble-bed reactor—presents unique risks that have not been arguably addressed:

“The Board’s decision to ignore critical evidence and accept Long Mott Energy’s unjustified assertion that containment-free reactors can satisfy NRC’s regulations poses a direct threat to the health and safety of Texans and the broader U.S. public,” said Dr. Edwin Lyman, director of nuclear power safety at the Union of Concerned Scientists (UCS), a nonprofit group. “Long Mott Energy will still need to prove its claims later to obtain NRC operating licenses for these reactors, but even if the fuel proves defective there is no way that the NRC would order the company to retrofit the reactors with containments after they are built.”

According to Dr. Lyman, the fuel balls inside the proposed Dow/X-energy reactor, will become “enormously more radioactive than when they first entered the reactor.” They will become high-level radioactive waste (irradiated or ‘spent’ fuel), which can give a lethal dose in a few minutes if unshielded. 

Texas and the surrounding community should assume that all of the waste will be kept on site indefinitely. Neither LME nor the NRC has even estimated if or how long the waste from pebble bed nuclear reactors can be stored and how dangerous the site will be as soon as the reactors start and for the thousands of centuries the waste stays radioactive.

For the local community, specifically the fishing industry dependent on the health of the San Antonio Bay, the stakes are existential. 

Diane Wilson, the executive director of San Antonio Bay Estuarine Waterkeeper and a 2023 Goldman Environmental Prize winner, emphasized the disconnect between Dow’s economic retreat from the region via layoffs and its simultaneous push for an expensive industrial experiment in South Texas:

“Dow is laying off thousands of Texans while at the same time seeking to build a wildly expensive experimental nuclear reactor in our backyard. (We) won’t stop until this radioactive experiment on South Texas and our bay is terminated.”

“FIRST GET YOUR FACTS STRAIGHT; THEN YOU CAN DISTORT THEM AS MUCH AS YOU WANT,” – Mark Twain

By David Kraft, Director

Nuclear Energy Information Service, Chicago

As a critical component of advancing the nuclear power juggernaut on an ill-informed public, for several years now pro-nuclear cheerleaders have been working feverishly to get state legislatures to repeal state-mandated moratoria on new nuclear plant construction.

The Biden and now Trump Administrations both have lavished tens-of-billions of dollars on promoting the nuclear fetish. Both also turned the Dept. of Energy into a pro bono advertising arm for the nuclear industry, which conducted numerous promo tours, photo ops and produced slick literature and advertisements asserting the “need” for more nuclear power.  

But this promotional effort was not confined to mere government operations.  The mainstream media was heavily incorporated into the effort to once again (our third “Nuclear Renaissance” this century) try to sell nuclear power to the public, by any rationalization necessary (whether truthful or not): a  predicted – if as yet unsubstantiated —  energy shortage from data centers; a “nuclear power gap” with China and other international sellers; minimization of energy efficiency, renewables and storage; promises of reactors that will “eat” radioactive wastes, be meltdown-proof, are fully portable and mass-produced, be “cheap” to build, and provide “cheap” electricity – just to name a few of the promo points.

While all these glittering baubles were dazzling the public and their legislators, virtually no serious mention let alone detailed discussion of the numerous and universally unstated liabilities of nuclear power ever appear – proving that lies of omission can often be worse than lies of commission.

A prime example of this media propaganda campaign was a recent Washington Post editorial (Jan. 15, 2026)., praising Illinois Governor JB Pritzker and the state legislature for finally “seeing the nuclear light” by repealing Illinois’ 39-year old nuclear construction moratorium. As an Illinois nuclear power watchdog organization for 45 years, we wrote a rebuttal op-ed to correct the numerous “facts” of commission and omission in the WaPo’s op-ed on “the ‘facts’ about nuclear energy” here in Illinois – which of course they did not publish.

First, nuclear plant construction moratoria are not “bans.” The enormously significant difference is that construction is conditionally prohibited until the dangerous high-level radioactive waste (HLRW) produced by nuclear plants are given an environmentally responsible final and permanent place for disposal. The federal government was supposed to have provided a facility by 1997.  It failed to do so then, and continues to fail to this day.  Making more waste absent responsible permanent disposal methods is societally unacceptable and environmentally dangerous – a fact government and media nuclear cheerleaders routinely ignore.  We still have no permanent disposal methodology or facility for the ~100,000 tons of HLRW already produced, which grows annually in the U.S. by nearly 2,000 tons.  Building new reactors adding even more waste absent an operational disposal facility is – criminal.

Concerns about radioactive waste disposal are not trivial.  A study conducted by a team of experts which included former Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) Chairwoman Alison Macfarlane determined that, depending on the design, the currently mythical “small modular reactors” (SMRs) would produce 2 to 30 times as much radioactive waste per unit of energy delivered compared to today’s “old fashioned” reactors.

Second, Illinois Governor Pritzker’s stated concerns about a lack of safety are now borne out as totally justified by President Trump’s recent Executive Orders which cut staff at the NRC while simultaneously calling for a quadrupling of nuclear capacity; shift new reactor licensing emphasis to speed over safety; allow for higher levels of “allowable” radiation exposure for the public; and allow DOGE personnel to overrule some NRC licensing decisions.  Recently, the President has suggested that private entities using nuclear power for data centers could get operating licenses within three weeks – as opposed to the years of thorough engineering review it now takes.  What could possibly go wrong?

Pritzker’s concerns about new large reactor costs are borne out by the most recent Lazard’s analysis (June 2025) of levelized costs, indicating new reactors as more expensive than new solar, on- and off-shore wind, and energy storage.  Projected costs for mythical SMRs vary wildly, but seem to be following this same trend.

Polling reports of increased public support should not come as a surprise.  Like all public opinion, it is driven by money spent and media saturation achieved.  Both the Biden Administration and now the Trump junta over the past five years have used the DOE’s bully-pulpit to lavish tens of millions of dollars into promotional nuclear power propaganda directed at the public, and bestowed huge grants to pro-nuclear projects.  Coupled with current panic-peddling over data center electrical demand and rising costs for electricity, and the Trump Administration’s ill-informed and pathologic policies towards viable renewable energy alternatives, they have driven a poorly informed, if not indoctrinated public to the dubious conclusion that new nuclear is a “necessity.”

Finally, not surprisingly the WaPo op-ed joins government and industry nuclear cheerleaders, in being totally silent about the inconvenient nuclear power side effects like nuclear security, environmental justice, just transitions for reactor communities, proliferation impacts, and the fact that wind and solar combined (and more, including storage) produce more electricity both in the U.S. and worldwide than all operating nuclear power reactors – cheaper, and without radioactive waste and nuclear safety/security concerns.

Ironically, it was a FoxNews analyst who once quipped that while facts may change opinions, opinions will NEVER change the facts.  Deliberately cherry picking and omitting inconvenient facts is not journalism, or responsible editorializing – it’s propaganda. It should be treated as such by the public, and with the healthy skepticism it deserves.

By The Nuclear Skeptic

New York Governor Kathy Hochul’s desire to build 5GW of new nuclear power in order to keep New York’s electric bills affordable and meet future energy demand has one pesky problem: the numbers simply don’t add up. That’s the overarching conclusion of a new report authored by the University of Pennsylvania’s Dr. Joseph Romm, which was presented in New York last week. 

Echoing the Trump administration’s desire to revive the nuclear energy industry from its global downturn over the past few decades, Governor Hochul and President Trump appear to be in lock-step in their shared desire to build new nuclear reactors, despite the economic reality that cheaper and faster power alternatives exist and are already being utilized across the globe to meet growing electricity needs. There are a myriad of possible reasons why both politicians believe new nuclear generation is a viable option moving forward, but it’s clear neither are paying attention to what just happened in Georgia  – when two incumbent Republican Public Service Commission (PSC) members were removed from office by voters  following massive increases in consumer electric bills. To be fair, neither Hochul nor Trump will be around to face the music if their plans are realized and New York starts the decades-long process to build 5GW worth of the world’s most expensive source of energy.  

Keeping the lights on and affordable should be a top priority for any politician in the current economic landscape but there is a clear disconnect between major decisions about our future energy grid being made today and the future ramifications of those decisions both economically and electorally. New sources of affordable and clean electricity are needed to power data centers, vehicle electrification and other sources of new demand, but it’s unclear how much electricity is truly needed and how fast. According to AI proponents, New York and the U.S. at large are going to need massive amounts of new electric power and fast. For example, New York’s Master Energy Plan anticipates nearly 40GW of new power needed by 2040, therefore doubling New York’s current energy supply in the next 15 years.

Setting aside the (very real) possibility of the AI data center bubble bursting far before 2040, Hochul and Trump are calling for more nuclear generation to meet energy demand predictions and both have cited nuclear’s “affordability” as reason why. Well, as Romm’s recent report concludes, this is pure fantasy. 

Romm notes that Georgia’s two new reactors at Plant Vogtle, which went online in 2024 after nearly two decades of construction and delays, resulted in a 25% percent increase in consumer electric bills. The ~2GW from the twin Vogtle reactors cost more than $36 billion, 2.5+ times more than original estimates! But that sudden spike in electric bills is just the tip of the iceberg. The recent spike doesn’t account for the billions of taxpayer dollars currently subsidizing the plant, the billions in loans from the Department of Energy used to build it, nor does it account for the high cost of servicing debt and ongoing operations into the future which will inevitably require further subsidization – similar to New York’s $33 billion in state subsidies going towards the existing reactors at Ginna, Nine Mile Point, and FitzPatrick accounting for 5.4GW in capacity. Simply put, Georgia’s two new reactors are the most expensive electricity on the planet and for a myriad of reasons not related to “affordability,” both Trump and Hochul want to recreate that terrible recipe.

But the most disturbing finding in Romm’s report is what was buried in the middle of the NY Master Energy Plan. The plan inexplicably does not include cost or cost overrun figures, instead references a separate analysis used to inform the state’s approach. Hochul’s team, in Trump-like fashion, has decided to ignore its own experts, relying on financial figures included in a separate report by a NYSERDA ‘contractor’ that begins with the unprecedented disclaimer: 

“NYSERDA, the State of New York, and the contractor make no warranties or representations, expressed or implied, as to … the usefulness, completeness, or accuracy of any processes, methods, or other information contained, described, disclosed, or referred to in this report. NYSERDA, the State of New York, and the contractor … will assume no liability for any loss, injury, or damage resulting from, or occurring in connection with, the use of information contained, described, disclosed, or referred to in this report.”

To sum it up, the plan to build 5GW of new nuclear generation in New York is based on an economic analysis that might as well be a science fiction novel. The basic assumption of the “contractors’” economic analysis is that the cost to build reactors in New York, notorious for its cheap construction costs, will be cheaper than at Plant Vogtle in Georgia. Did anyone on Hochul’s team ask Plant Vogtle’s construction monitor if this was achievable? Apparently not. 

Anyone who claims new nuclear power plants in New York will lower your electric bill is lying. We should ask why? Why is Hochul drinking the nuclear kool-aid? I don’t believe New York will actually build and operate a new nuclear reactor any time soon, but like the cancelled-after-spending-$9-billion-dollars twin reactors at South Carolina’s VC Summer, or the abandoned-after-spending-$6-billion dollars reactor at Shoreham which Long Islanders are still paying for, there’s a lot of money still on the table. Our money. 

The full article by Karl Grossman and Harvey Wasserman, originally published on December 24, 2025 in CounterPunch, is available here.

The Trump family is now directly investing in atomic energy.  Its money-losing Truth Social company has become a part owner of a major fusion nuclear power project.

Among much more, the investments mean the Trump family stands to profit directly from White House attacks on wind, solar and other cheap, clean renewable energies which for decades have been driving fusion, fission and fossil fuels toward economic oblivion.

“A Trump-sponsored business is once again betting on an industry that the president has championed, further entwining his personal fortunes in sectors that his administration is both supporting and overseeing,” reported an article on the front page of the business section of the New York Times last week. “This one is in the nuclear power sector. TAE Technologies, which is developing fusion energy, said on Thursday that it planned to merge with Trump Media & Technology Group. President Trump is the largest shareholder of the money-losing social media and crypto investment firm that bears his name, and he will remain a major investor in the combined company.”

The headline of the piece: “Trump’s Push Into Nuclear Is Raising Questions.”

The primary asks have to do with economic conflicts of interest, and public safety.

“The deal, should it be completed,” the article continued, “would put Mr. Trump in competition with other energy companies over which his administration holds financial and regulatory sway. Already, the president has sought to gut safety oversight of nuclear power plants and lower thresholds for human radiation exposure.”

CNN reported: “Nuclear fusion companies are regulated by the federal government and will likely need Uncle Sam’s deep research and even deeper pockets to become commercially viable. The merger needs to be approved by federal regulators—some of whom were nominated by Trump.”

CNN quoted Richard Painter, chief White House ethics lawyer under President George W. Bush, as saying: “There is a clear conflict of interest here. Every other president since the Civil War has divested from business interests that would conflict with official duties. President Trump has done the opposite.” Painter is now a professor at the University of Minnesota Law School.

“Having the president and his family have a large stake in a particular energy source is very problematic,” said Peter A. Bradford, who previously served on the Nuclear Regulatory Commission, the agency meant to oversee the nuclear industry in the United States, in the Times article.

“The Trump administration has sought to accelerate nuclear power technology—including fusion, which remains unproven,” Bradford said. “That support has come in the form of federal loans and grants, as well as executive orders directing the NRC to review and approve applications more quickly.”

Still, the White House press secretary, Karoline Leavitt, said in a statement that “neither the president nor his family have ever engaged, or will ever engage, in conflicts of interest.” And the Times piece continued, “a spokeswoman for Trump Media” said the company was “scrupulously following all applicable rules and regulations, and any hypothetical speculation about ethics violations is wholly unsupported by the facts.”

It went on that “Trump’s stake in Trump Media, recently valued at $1.6 billion, is held in a trust managed by Donald Trump Jr., his eldest son. Trump Media is the parent company of Truth Social, the struggling social-media platform. The merger would set Trump Media in a new strategic direction, while giving TAE a stock market listing as it continues to develop its nuclear fusion technology.”

The Guardian quoted the CEO of Trump Media, Devin Nunes, the arch-conservative former member of the House of Representatives from California and close to Trump, who is currently chair of the President’s Intelligence Advisory Board, saying Trump Media has “built un-cancellable infrastructure to secure free expression online for Americans. And now we’re taking a big step forward toward a revolutionary technology that will cement America’s global energy dominance for generations.” Nunes is the would be co-CEO of the merged company.

A current member of the US House, Don Beyer, a Democrat from Virginia, said in a statement quoted in Politico that the deal raises “significant concerns” about conflicts of interest and avenues for potential corruption. “The President has consistently used both government powers and taxpayer money to benefit his own financial interests and those of his family and political allies. This merger will necessitate congressional oversight to ensure that the U.S. government and public funds are properly directed towards fusion research and development in ways that benefit the American people, as opposed to the Trump family and their corporate holdings.”

By federal law (the Price-Anderson Act of 1957) the US commercial atomic power industry has been shielded from liability in major accidents it might cause. The “Nuclear Clause” in every US homeowner’s insurance policy explicitly denies coverage for losses or damages caused, directly or indirectly, caused by a nuclear reactor accident.

As his company fuses with the atomic industry, Trump acquires a direct financial interest in gutting atomic oversight—which he has already been busy doing. In June Trump fired NRC Chairman Christopher T. Hanson. No other president has ever fired an NRC Commissioner.

Earlier, more than 100 NRC staff were purged by Elon Musk’s DOGE operation. There has been a stream of Trump executive orders calling for a sharp reduction in radiation standards, expedited approval by the NRC of nuclear plant license applications, and a demand to quadruple nuke power in the United States—from the current 100 gigawatts to 400 gigawatts in 2050. Such a move would require huge federal subsidies and the virtual obliteration of safety regulations. Trump has essentially ordered the NRC to “rubber stamp” all requests from a nuclear industry in which he is now directly invested.

Trump’s Truth Social’s fusion ownership stake removes all doubt about any regulatory neutrality. No presently operating or proposed US atomic reactor can be considered certifiably safe.

Read more here.